Ask a founder for their gross margin and you’ll get a number. Ask for their margin at UNFI, net of deductions, last quarter against the same quarter last year, and the room usually goes quiet.
That second number is the one that decides where you should grow. This piece is about how to get it, and how to read it.
What we mean by trade rate
Trade rate is what it costs you to sell through a channel: promotions, allowances, fees and other deductions, expressed as a percentage of that channel’s sales. It is the gap between the price on your invoice and the cash that comes back.
Two channels with the same list price can have very different trade rates. One runs heavier promotions, another charges more fees, a third sees more shortages. Until you measure it per channel, you’re averaging a good account with a difficult one and calling it margin.
Why the blended number hides the problem
Most brands see deductions as one line in the P&L. That line is accurate, and almost useless for decisions, because it can’t tell you:
- which distributor, retailer or chain the deductions came from
- which promotions cost more than planned
- whether shortages are concentrated in one channel
- whether this quarter is better or worse than the same quarter last year
Those are the questions behind real decisions: which promotion to renew, which account to renegotiate, and where the next dollar of trade spend should go.
Three cuts worth looking at
By channel
Deductions as a percent of sales for each distributor, retailer and chain, with the margin impact next to it. This is the view that tells you whether a channel that looks big is actually profitable.
By deduction type
Split each channel by MCB, shortage, OI, damage and spoils. A high trade rate driven by promotions is a planning conversation. One driven by shortages is an operations conversation.
Over time
Compare any two periods, year over year. A trade rate that is creeping up is far easier to fix early than to explain later.

Example chart of deductions as a percent of sales for UNFI, KeHE, Target, Walmart and Costco, comparing Q3 2026 with Q3 2025. Four of the five channels are lower than last year; Walmart is slightly higher.
Reading the numbers without overreacting
A higher trade rate isn’t automatically bad. A promotion that drove volume can be worth every point. What you’re looking for is the gap between what you planned to spend and what was actually deducted, and the deductions that should never have happened at all.
- Separate planned from unplanned. Promotions you agreed to are planned. Shortages, unexplained fees and duplicate claims are not.
- Check the unplanned against your documents. Some of it will be recoverable.
- Watch the trend, not the month. One heavy month is noise. Three in a row is a pattern.

Closing the loop with accounting
Analytics only helps if the numbers agree with your books. In Roma, deduction management, analytics and accounting share the same data, so the number you dispute is the number you book.
- Every remittance matched to invoices and deductions
- Custom GL code mapping and standardized deduction classification
- A full audit trail
- Export to CSV, NetSuite or QuickBooks
Roma doesn’t replace your accounting or ERP system. It works alongside it. And with forecasting based on 12-month trends, you can plan next year’s trade spend from what actually happened, not from what the plan said would happen.
Want to see your own trade rate by channel? Book a demo and we’ll show you your numbers.





